Title: Who Is To Blame?: A Russian Riddle
Author: Jane Marlow
Publisher: River Grove Books
Publication Date: 2016
Format: EBook - EPUB
Genre: Historical Fiction
Source: ARC via NetGalley
Jane Marlow’s debut novel
is a beautifully written twenty-five-year saga of two families—one born
of noble heritage and the other bound as serfs to the noble’s household.
Set during the mid-1800s in the vast grainfields of Russia, Who Is to
Blame? follows the lives of two star-crossed serfs, Elizaveta and
Feodor, torn apart by their own families and the Church while
simultaneously trapped in the inhumane life of poverty to which they
At the other end of the spectrum, Count Maximov and
his family struggle to maintain harmony amidst a tapestry of deception
and debauchery woven by the Count’s son. The plot twists further when
the Tsar emancipates twenty million serfs from bondage while the rural
gentry’s life of privilege and carelessness has taken its final bow and
much of Russia’s nobility faces possible financial ruin. (Goodreads Synopsis)
Who Is To Blame? is a book about which I could not quite make up my mind. I loved the plot idea and interesting period setting; however, the characters came across as too 2D for my liking. I never got to know them emotionally. Their actions were reported to me, but there was no connection. I didn't care what happened to any of them. A few of them also seemed rather stereotypical. Mid-nineteenth century Russia is not a topic on which I've read a great deal of non-fiction, therefore I was willing to accept Marlow's portrayal as accurate even though, to me, the count did a lot of things I would have thought he'd delegate. But perhaps that's just him and/or because he's minor nobility and not Petersburg high society.
One thing I would say as a positive for this story, though, is that it makes a good introductory piece to 'Russian' literature. For those who find the works of Tolstoy and Dostoevsky a bit daunting, Who Is To Blame? is an excellent midway text to ease you in and prepare you for tackling those works with their huge casts and complicated Russian naming patterns.
Overall, I would say that Who Is To Blame? , while not without its faults, is a pleasant, easy historical fiction read.